Book Review: Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-earth

Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-Earth
By J.R.R. Tolkien
Edited by Christopher Tolkien

Unfinished Tales of Númenor and Middle-Earth is the first book in a study of the many fragments of Tolkien’s writing on his legendarium. Tolkien’s son Christopher collects several lengthy fragments stretching from the First Age of Middle-earth to the beginning of the Fourth Age, expanding upon material previously found only in the appendices to The Lord of the Rings and The Silmarillion. The younger Tolkien also includes copious notes, both by his father and himself, which further expand upon the fragments in this volume.

The book is divided into four parts; the first three each containing legends and essays relating to the first three ages of Middle-earth, with the fourth containing three essays on specific topics: the Drúedain, the Istari, and the Palantíri. Between The Silmarillion and the recently published The Children of Húrin, much of the material in Part One is covered extensively elsewhere in finished form. Of the most interest to me was the tale of “Aldarion and Erendis,” from the Second Age, and the tale of “Cirion and Eorl and the Friendship of Gondor and Rohan,” from the Third Age.

Whether a true Tolkien addict (like myself) or a casual fan of Tolkien’s writing, this book has a little something for everyone. The extensive footnotes and research makes this book a must-read for those fascinated by the intricate world only glimpsed at through The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, while those wishing a less-immersive experience can skip the essays and read only the stories. This book left me wanting to read the rest of my Tolkien collection again, which to me is always a sign of a good book. I would highly recommend Unfinished Tales to all fans of fantasy literature, especially those with a deep love of Tolkien’s writing.

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-unfinished-tales-of-numenor-and-middle-earth/

Book Review: The High King

The High King
The Chronicles of Prydain, Book 5
By Lloyd Alexander

In the conclusion to the Chronicles, all Prydain is at war. Arawn, Lord of Annuvin, has attacked Prince Gwydion and stolen the magical sword Dyrnwyn. Gwydion rides to recover the sword, but the companions soon learn the threat is greater than they ever imagined. Arawn is gathering his forces and means to attack Caer Dathyl, seat of High King Math.

Faced with lies and betrayal, Taran and his friends fight a losing battle to protect the fortress of the Sons of Don. When the high king falls to Arawn’s deathless Cauldron-Born, Lord Gwydion brings the battle to the Lord of Death’s doorstep in a desperate attempt to rid Prydain of his evil.

The High King is filled with excitement, adventure, and enough battle and glory to satisfy the heart of any assistant pig-keeper. Many things are finally revealed, including the secrets surrounding Taran’s parents and his ultimate destiny. This book is a must-read for fans of Prydain and I would recommend it to all fans of fantasy literature.

This review originally appeared 6 April 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-high-king/

Book Review: Taran Wanderer

Taran Wanderer
The Chronicles of Prydain, Book 4
By Lloyd Alexander

With Eilonwy learning to be a princess on the Isle of Mona, Taran is desperate to discover his parentage, hoping to be born of royalty. Dallben gives him permission to seek his parents, and Taran sets out with Gurgi by his side. Taran’s quest leads them through the Marshes of Morva and to the furthest ends of Prydain. Along the way, Taran is offered a kingdom, spends the winter with a shepherd, and apprentices under a blacksmith, a weaver, and a potter.

In his quest to discover his birthright, Taran learns bitter lessons of loss and disappointment, but finds friends in unexpected places. He also discovers that luck is not something a person has, but is instead something a person creates. He is offered a kingdom, but is wise enough to realize that abandoning his quest would forever haunt him.

More so than the rest of the series, Taran Wanderer focuses on Taran and his wish to more than an orphaned assistant pig-keeper. While his companions play major parts in the rest of the series, Gurgi is the only character in this adventure who is a constant companion to Taran, with Eilonwy only ever present in Taran’s thoughts. I thoroughly enjoyed this adventure and would recommend it to any fans of fantasy or Prydain.

This review originally appeared 30 March 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-taran-wanderer/

Book Review: The Castle of Llyr

The Castle of Llyr
The Chronicles of Prydain, Book 3
By Lloyd Alexander

Princess Eilonwy is sent to the Isle of Mona to learn to be a lady, and Taran and Gurgi accompany her on the voyage. Shortly after their arrival, Taran is warned that Eilonwy’s life is in danger. Failing to protect her from being kidnapped, Taran and Gurgi, joined by Fflweddur Fflam and the clumsy prince of Mona, set out on a quest to rescue the princess.

The Isle of Mona holds several wonders for the companions, including an oversized mountain cat, a whiny giant in an underground cave, and the ruins of Caer Colur, the ancestral home of Eilonwy’s family. Taran’s feelings for Eilonwy are brought to the surface by the prospect of her marriage to the Prince of Mona, and his true maturity is revealed in his actions toward the prince.

The Castle of Llyr is an excellent addition to The Chronicles of Prydain. Like the previous novels in the series, it can be read alone, but is much richer when read with a greater understanding of the characters. I would recommend The Castle of Llyr to all fans of fantasy and the writings of Lloyd Alexander.

This review originally appeared 23 March 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-castle-of-llyr/

Book Review: The Black Cauldron

The Black Cauldron
The Chronicles of Prydain, Book 2
By Lloyd Alexander

Prince Gwydion calls a council of war at Caer Dallben and Taran is invited. To prevent Arawn, lord of Annuvin, from creating more of his deathless Cauldron-Born, Gwydion proposes an expedition to Annuvin to steal Arawn’s cauldron. While Gwydion, Coll, and Fflewddur Fflam enter Annuvin, Taran finds himself on guard duty near the gate, teamed up with the wise son of the chief bard and an arrogant prince. Fflewddur soon returns, reporting the cauldron has already been stolen, and the companions set out on a quest which will lead them through the treacherous Marshes of Morva.

In the second installment of The Chronicles of Prydain, Taran learns valuable lessons about becoming a man and a great leader. The true measure of his growth is shown when he is forced to choose between a magic brooch of wisdom and the black cauldron.

The Black Cauldron is an excellent addition to Alexander’s Chronicles and I would recommend it to any fan of the fantasy genre. The book is written as a stand-alone novel, but the story gains more depth when read in its proper place in the series.

This review originally appeared 16 March 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-black-cauldron/

Book Review: The Book of Three

The Book of Three
The Chronicles of Prydain, Book 1
By Lloyd Alexander

Set in the fictional land of Prydain, The Book of Three follows the adventures of Taran, an Assistant Pig-Keeper, as he seeks to find his lost sow, the oracular pig Hen Wen. Frightened by the dreaded Horned King, Hen Wen escaped her pen at Caer Dallben, running into the nearby forest. Taran chases her and is soon embroiled in a myriad of adventures. Along the way, he makes several new friends, including Gwydion, prince of the Sons of Don, Eilonwy, princess of Llyr, Fflewddur Fflam, a wandering bard and king of a small realm, Gurgi, a small sasquatch-like creature, and Doli, a dwarf of the Fair Folk.

While the book tells a story of adventure, it’s mainly about a young boy learning the value of friendship and that what he really wants is what he already had. At Caer Dallben, Taran longs for honor and glory won in battle, but soon learns there is as much honor in a field well-plowed as in a sword well-wielded. Although not yet fully a man on his return, Taran has learned valuable lessons about life during his adventures.

Growing up, The Chronicles of Prydain were some of my favorite fantasy novels, second only to the works of J.R.R. Tolkien and followed closely by The Chronicles of Narnia. They are written for a younger audience, but as an adult I still find them enjoyable and love reading them whenever I have the opportunity. I would recommend The Book of Three and the entire Chronicles of Prydain to all fans of fantasy.

This review originally appeared 9 March 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-book-of-three/

The Mabinogion and The Chronicles of Prydain

Most fantasy books draw upon myths and legends in some way or another, even if only in their use of such fantastical creatures as dragons and elves. Lloyd Alexander’s The Chronicles of Prydain is one such series, based on the Welsh legends in The Mabinogion.

While the plots of his Chronicles are original, Alexander draws heavily on his sources for most of his characters and locations. Prydain itself is modeled after his memories of Wales when he served there during World War II. He described Prydain as being Wales “more as it never was” than an actual representation of the country.

Of the main human characters in the series, only Eilonwy and Taran are not directly based on chararacters from Welsh legends, although they both embody characteristics of many heroes and heroines in The Mabinogion.

The most evident example of this is in one of Taran’s mentors, the prince Gwydion. In both The Chronicles of Prydain and The Mabinogion, Gwydion is a relative of King Math, son of Mathonwy, and possesses some powers of enchantment. Unlike Alexander’s heroic interpretation of the character, the Gwydion of Welsh mythology is somewhat of a troublemaker.

This article originally appeared 14 January 2012 on mythsoftheworld.blogspot.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/the-mabinogion-and-the-chronicles-of-prydain/

Book Review: The Foundling and Other Tales of Prydain

The Foundling and Other Tales of Prydain
By Lloyd Alexander

The Foundling and Other Tales of Prydain is a collection of short stories set in the world of The Chronicles of Prydain. First published in 1973, five years after the last book in the Chronicles, this collection of short stories is set before the events of the series. The original collection was composed of six stories: “The Foundling,” “The Stone,” “The True Enchanter,” “The Rascal Crow,” “The Sword,” and “The Smith, the Weaver, and the Harper,” with “Coll and His White Pig” and “The Truthful Harp” added in 1999.

“The Foundling” is set several years before the Chronicles and tells the story of the enchanter Dallben’s childhood. Raised by three hags in the Marshes of Morva, Dallben gains all wisdom after accidently tasting a potion from their cauldron. The hags send him into the world, giving him The Book of Three as a parting gift.

“The Stone” is set immediately after “The Foundling” and tells the story of a farmer’s brush with eternal youth. After encountering the aged Dallben on the road, Maibon wishes to never grow old. Later that day, he encounters Doli of the Fair Folk, who gives him a stone that will keep him from getting any older.

“The True Enchanter” is a love story, set in the Prydainian kingdom of Llyr a little more than a decade before the Chronicles. Princess Angharad of the Royal House of Llyr is required by law to marry an enchanter, but wishes instead to marry for love.

“The Rascal Crow” is set an unknown length of time before the series. It tells the story of Kadwyr the crow’s disdain of the other animals’ skills and how his pride and overconfidence nearly cost him his life.

“The Sword,” set in Prydain’s ancient history, is a tale of the great sword Dyrnwyn and the king who misused it, losing his nobility and eventually his life.

“The Smith, the Weaver, and the Harper,” also set in Prydain’s ancient history, tells the story of Arawn, Lord of Death, and his quest to rid Prydain of magical instruments which possess the knowledge of their craftsman.

“Coll and His White Pig,” first published as a picture book in 1965, is set a decade or two before the Chronicles. It tells the story of Arawn’s theft of the pig Hen Wen and Coll’s daring rescue of her.

“The Truthful Harp,” first published as a picture book in 1967, is set an unknown number of years before the Chronicles, but likely not more than a decade or two. It tells the story of Fflewddur Flam’s quest to be a bard and the harp given him to tame his habit of embellishing the facts.

Since all of these stories are set before The Chronicles of Prydain I always read them first, but I believe The Foundling and Other Tales of Prydain should be read last by a first-time reader. Most of the characters and events in these stories are referred to in the series, and this background gives a deeper meaning to the stories.

I think The Foundling is probably my favorite of the bunch. Dallben’s quest for knowledge shows that while the world is filled with pain and suffering, there is always hope. I would definitely recommend this collection to fans of Prydain, but it will likely have little meaning to anyone else.

This review originally appeared 2 March 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-foundling-and-other-tales-of-prydain/

Book Review: The King of Elfland’s Daughter

The King of Elfland’s Daughter
By Lord Dunsany

In the kingdom of Erl, the citizens appear before the king and ask for a magic lord to rule over them, thinking that magic will make Erl known throughout the world. Though the king knows they will come to regret their decision, he agrees to send his eldest son to marry Lirazel, the king of Elfland’s daughter.

The borders of Elfland are a day’s journey from Erl, and the son, Alveric, sets out the next morning with a magic sword to defeat the elvish weapons. After passing through a magic wood inside the borders of Elfland, Alveric met the princess and they fell in love.

The king’s knights attack Alveric, but he defeats them with his magic sword. Alveric and Lirazel leave the land of the elves, returning to the world of men before the king of Elfland can try to stop them. Upon their return, Alveric discovers his father has died and he is crowned the new king of Erl. Alveric and Lirazel are married immediately, and soon a son is born to them.

Over time, Lirazel begins to grow dissatisfied with the strange ways of men. She longs for her life in Elfland, and her father prepares a way for her to return. Speaking the rune, she is magically transported back to her father and the borders of Elfland disappear from the lands near Erl. Heartbroken over the loss of his wife, Alveric sets out on a quest to return to Elfland and bring back his queen, leaving his young son in the care of his nurse.

The King of Elfland’s Daughter is a classic and one of the major forerunners of modern fantasy fiction. The works of Lord Dunsany have inspired many fantasy authors, including J.R.R. Tolkien. I really enjoyed this book and I was unable to put it down. I finished it in a matter of hours, but it’s also not as thick as many modern fantasy novels.

The writing style is different from that of most modern fantasy works, adopting a more conversational tone reminiscent of The Hobbit or The Chronicles of Narnia. Some readers may find this style boring as it allows for less character interaction, but I found it refreshing. It felt like I was reading an actual fairy tale rather that a novel. I would definitely recommend this book to all lovers of fantasy and fairy tales. Even if you don’t care for the conversational style, it’s interesting to see the roots of modern fantasy.

This review originally appeared 2 February 2013 on fantasyreviewer.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/book-review-the-king-of-elflands-daughter/

The Childhood of Christ

Madonna with the Christ Child

“Madonna with the Christ Child” by Giovanni Battista Salvi da Sassoferrato.
Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Aside from his birth and a brief incident in the temple at the age of twelve, the Christian Bible gives little information concerning the early years of Jesus of Nazareth. What events transpired during the family’s sojourn in Egypt? When did Christ perform his first miracle? While these questions are not answered in the biblical narrative, several pseudepigraphal Christian works give possible accounts from Christ’s early life.

According to the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew, Jesus was around a year old when the family left Judea for Egypt. During the journey, they sheltered in a cave, which was discovered to be inhabited by dragons. Jesus climbed down from Mary’s lap and the dragons worship him, then depart in peace. The family often encounters wild lions and panthers during the journey, which also worship Jesus and leave in peace.

Three days into their journey, Mary rested beside a palm tree. When she expressed a desire for some of the tree’s fruit, Jesus caused the tree to bend toward her. When the hungry travelers had gathered all of the fruit, Jesus commanded the tree to raise back up and a fountain of water to gush from its roots to fill their empty water skins. When Joseph complained of the heat a few days later, Jesus shortened the remainder of the journey from thirty days to one day. They then visited a city in Egypt and entered a local temple, where all of the idols bowed to Jesus and then shattered into pieces.

After returning from Egypt, Jesus, age four, builds a system of pools which receive water from an aqueduct. When another boy smashes the aqueduct, Jesus causes him to die. The boy’s parents complain and Joseph entreats Mary to talk to Jesus. She convinces him to bring the boy back to life.

The fragmentary Infancy Gospel of Thomas, not to be confused with the gnostic Gospel of Thomas, gives an account of the five-year-old Jesus playing near a stream after a rainstorm on the Sabbath day. The water is muddy and the child commands the water to form tiny lakes and become clear again. He then molds twelve sparrows out of the mud from the rain. A nearby Jew sees Jesus molding sparrows on the Sabbath and hurries to tell Joseph. When Joseph rebukes Jesus for breaking the Sabbath, Christ performs a miracle and brings the sparrows to life. After the sparrows fly away, a nearby boy scatters the water in Jesus’s pools with a willow branch. Angry, Jesus curses the boy and he becomes withered all over. When the boy’s parents complain to Joseph, Jesus heals the boy, leaving a small part of him withered as a warning.

Another incident is told of a boy who bumped Jesus’s shoulder as he ran by. Jesus commanded the boy to go no further, and the boy fell down dead. When the people in the village complain to Joseph, Jesus curses them with blindness. The Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew omits the blindness, instead recounting that Jesus also brought this boy back to life.

A few days later, Joseph sent Jesus to a schoolmaster named Zacchæus. When Zacchæus attempts to teach Jesus the first letter of the alphabet, Jesus opens a book and teaches Zacchæus about the prophets. He then heals all of the surrounding people of their diseases.

Following these incidents, Pseudo-Matthew tells of the family’s relocation to Nazareth. While playing with some friends, one boy pushes another off a roof, and Jesus is blamed by the dead boy’s parents. He brings the dead boy back to life, and the boy clears Jesus’s name. The family then relocates to Jericho.

Now six years old, Jesus is sent to draw water at a fountain. His pitcher accidentally gets broken, and he carries the water home in his cloak.

A few years later, a family of lions make their home near the road from Jericho to Jordan, preying on unwary travels. Jesus visits the family of lions, and the cubs play around his feet while the older lions worship him. The villagers gather at a safe distance and Jesus rebukes them for not glorifying him when even the beasts recognize their lord. He then crosses the Jordan, parting the waters for the lions to pass.

Another incident is told of a couch Joseph is asked to make. Joseph gives his servant the exact measurements, but the servant cuts one piece of wood too short. Jesus tells Joseph not to worry, and he stretches the short piece of wood to the proper length.

The family next relocates to Capernaum, where lives a rich man named Joseph. This Joseph dies, and Jesus sends his father to heal him with a handkerchief. Joseph places the handkerchief on the dead man’s face and commands him to be healed by Jesus. The man immediately arises and asks Joseph who Jesus is.

The next move is to Bethlehem, where Joseph’s eldest son James is bit by a viper while picking vegetables in the garden. Jesus heals James by blowing on his hand and the viper dies.

While several of the recounted miracles fit in nicely with the Christ of the biblical narrative, others cast Jesus as a petulant mischief-maker, a far cry from the dignity of the sinless Savior of Christianity. Most of the childhood miracles are likely fairy-tales, composed for the benefit of those wishing to know more of Christ’s life, but there may be germs of truth around which the narratives are woven.

SOURCES

Hone, William, comp. The Lost Books of the Bible. Trans. Jeremiah Jones and William Wake. New York: Bell Pub., 1979. Print.
Roberts, Alexander, and James Donaldson, eds. The Anti-Nicene Fathers. Vol. 8. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company. Internet Sacred Text Archive. Web. 6 July 2011. <http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/ecf/008/index.htm>.

This article originally appeared 16 July 2011 on mythsoftheworld.blogspot.com

Permanent link to this article: https://www.operationbrainleak.com/the-childhood-of-christ/